|
|
|
Selecting A Hard
Drive.
What To
Consider.
While most of our customers ask first about the capacity of the
hard drive, we often take them through a quick checklist of factors to
consider. The fact is, there may be differences between drives in the same
"class" (i.e.: speed, interface, price).
Here is that
checklist:
1. The Form
Factor
Be sure to ask about the physical size of the
drive. Are you utilizing a 3.5-inch bay or a
5.25-inch bay in your PC
case. Currently, the best choice is a 3.5-inch drive, since
they are
faster. If you have an open 5.25-inch bay and would like to install a
3.5-inch
drive, you can purchase an adapter kit. Notebook PCs use
2.5-inch drives.
2. Internal or
External?
Do you have an open bay in which to install
an internal drive? If not, you may consider
an external drive, which
simply plugs into an adapter in the rear of your PC. External
drives
are also useful when switching between PCs. NOTE: External hard drives
are
normally more expensive than internal models, and offer less
variety in sizes and
performance features.
3. Interface.
As mentioned earlier, information that you "save" to your
hard drive travels from the PC's. main memory to the hard drive via the
interface. The speed of this interface may vary
on different hard
drives. Here's an explanation...
| External Drives: USB and IEEE 1394
(FireWire) |
External hard drives
feature two common interface types; USB (Universal Serial Bus) and IEEE
1394 (also known as FireWire or iLink). FireWire is a higher performance
interface than USB, with a maximum bandwidth (the amount of data that can
flow across the interface in one second) of 50MB per second. USB's maximum
bandwidth is 1.5MB per second.
USB and FireWire are
"plug-and-play" interfaces. This means the drives can be connected and
disconnected without turning the computer off. Older PCs may not support
USB or FireWire, but you can purchase an adapter card for your PC (into a
PCI slot).
| Internal
Drives: EIDE and SCSI |
Internal drives are
avialble in two distinct types: EIDE (Enhanced Integrated Drive
Electronics) and SCSI (Small Computer Systems Interface). For performance,
you'll want to go with SCSI, which is later technology and more advanced.
SCSI is also more expensive than EIDE. EIDE is the most common type of
interface used in personal computers today. Increasingly, many internal
drives may also use the IEEE 1394 (FireWire) interface.
WHAT TO BUY: For most
computer users, EIDE is the best buy. It is inexpensive and very common.
If your PC activities are limited to the Internet, word processing, games,
etc., EIDE is adequate. In addition, most motherboards are are equipped to
handle EIDE drives. (However, many older motherboards may support only the
IDE standard, which is an earlier version of EIDE).
If you require better
performance, SCSI is an excellent solution. However, you may have to
purchase a SCSI "Host Adapter" (sometimes called a SCSI controller
card).
EIDE And SCSI
Comparison
| EIDE Drives |
|
 |
|
SCSI Drives
|
|
Advantages
Most motherboards are set up to support
EIDE drives. EIDE is easier to configure, provided you are not
connecting more than 4 drives (hard drive, DVD, CD-RW, etc.).
EIDE drives and
other devices are much less expensive than SCSI drives.
If you only have
a single drive connected, EIDE is often faster than SCSI! This is
due to the fact that SCSI includes a lot of additional
hardware/softwqare "overhead."
Disadvantages
EIDE delivers slower throughput than
SCSI. However newer ATA/66 and ATA/100 EIDE drives have increased
performance.
EIDE
motherboards include 2 EIDE channels. Two drives may be connected to
each channel, but only one channel can actually transfer data at a
time. The second drive on the channel must wait.
Although EIDE
drives can be configured as part of a RAID, it is not as effective
as using SCSI drives in a RAID.
|
Advantages
Superior technology gives SCSI a faster
data throughput than EIDE. This is particularly important when
working with large video or audio files.
More than one
SCSI device can transfer data along the interface at one time, for
better efficiency. SCSI has a much larger bandwidth that is fully
utilized. EIDE's bandwidth is not fully utilized.
SCSI devices
enable you to connect up to 15 devices to a single SCSI
bus.
SCSI supports a
wide range of peripherals, including scanners, etc.
SCSI is a better
choice for multitasking, configuring a RAID, extensive development
work and multiple-user support.
Disadvantages
EIDE delivers slower throughput than
SCSI. However newer ATA/66 and ATA/100 EIDE drives have increased
performance.
EIDE
motherboards include 2 EIDE channels. Two drives may be connected to
each channel, but only one channel can actually transfer data at a
time. The second drive on the channel must wait.
Although EIDE
drives can be configured as part of a RAID, it is not as effective
as using SCSI drives in a
RAID.
|
ADDITIONAL NOTES: EIDE (also
known as Ultra DMA) is available in three grades: ATA/33, ATA/66 and
ATA/100. The numbers (33, 66 and 100) represent the bandwidth. Every
motherboard description will include this bandwidth speed, and they are
backwards compatible: the ATA/100 will support ATA/66 and ATA/33. However,
the maximum bandwith that an ATA/100-equipped motherboard, with an
ATA/33-connected drive can deliver is 33MB per second. In other words,
while the motherboard will support the drive, it will not support the
speed. However, EIDE bandwidth can be increased with an adapter
card.
4. Internal Performance.
In addition to the interface bandwidth discussed above,
there are two other factors
to consider when evaluating the drive's
performance:
Internal Data Transfer Rate
An
important speed component, Internal Data Transfer Rate---measured in MB
per
second---refers to the time required to read the data requested
from the platters
and move it to the hard drive's cache buffer.
Transfer rate also refers to the reverse: how
much time required to
move data from the cache buffer then write it to the platters.
which
data is moved from the main memory to the platter(s).
There are two factors
that dramatically affect the drive's internal data transfer rate.
They
are: Areal Density and Spindle Speed. Areal Density refers to the
amount of data that is
packed onto a sector. More sectors per track
means that more data can be read in a
single revolution of the
platter. Spindle Speed refers to the speed at which the drive spins
it
platters, measured in RPM (revolutions per minute). So, the faster the
platters spin,
the faster data can be read (or written). This is the
basis of internal data transfer rate.
When selecting a hard
drive, be sure to check the drive's "sustained transfer rate"
(STR) or
"sequential transfer rate" specification. This specification tells you the
amount of
data that can be read from or written to a seqential series
of tracks in one second. The
specifications may also include
information on "head switch time" and "cylinder switch
time." Today,
high-end EIDE drives have a maximum STD of about 37MB per
second.
Maximum STD will be higher than Average STD. And of course,
SCSI drives will have
much higher STD rates than EIDE
drives.
You may be wondering:
If EIDE has a maximum STD of 37MB, what is the performance
advantage of
ATA/66 or ATA/100? Most of the time, there is no speed
advantage.
However, if the information you're requesting is already in
the cache buffer, it can be
transfered directly at what's known as a
"burst transfer rate," which can exploit the
ATA/66 or ATA/100 speed.
We recommend opting for the higher ATA/66 or ATA/100
rates, since there
are speed increases made when available.
Positioning
Performance is the speed at which the read/write heads need to
achieve
proper position over the appropriate sector for
recording.
When selecting a
drive, check the drive's "seek time" and "rotational
latency"
specifications. Seek time is the time required to position the
read/write heads over the
correct track. Rotational latency is the time
it takes the drive to rotate he required sector
into position under the
read/write head.
TECH
NOTES: Rotational latency is determined solely by the spindle speed. The
faster the platters spin, the less rotational latency. Most of today's
popular drives spin at 5400 rpm or 7200 rpm. Increasingly, manufacturers
are moving to 10,000 rpm, and many are available. Most 10,000 rpm models,
however, are SCSI drives, and some SCSI drives spin at up to 14,000
rpm.
Obviously, the faster
the platters spin, the better the performance. While 7200 rpm drives are
more expensive than 5400 rpm drives, the performance is quite
noticeable.
5. Capacity.
How much storage space do you need? This is simple. The
bigger the drive, the better.
Just a few years ago, a 1GB drive was
adequate for most users. Today. the industry
reports that 30GB is the
average drive capacity. With software applications requiring
an
ever-increasing amount of space to perform more complex
functions---and the need for
space to download materials from the
Internet, you should buy the largest hard drive
you can afford. And the
larger the hard drive, it usually follows that you'll pay less per
GB.
6.
Manufacturer.
Spend more and get a premium brand.
They offer better reliability, better warranty and
technical
support.
|